Moving Beyond the 10,000 Ways That Don't Work

Moving Beyond the 10,000 Ways That Don't Work

L. E. Bermudez¹; D. K. Arctur²; C. Rueda³

1. Southeastern Universities Research Association, Washington, DC, United States.
2. Open Geospatial Consortium, Inc., Austin, TX, United States.
3. Monterey Bay Aquarium Research Institute, Moss Landing, CA, United States.
 

From his research in developing light bulb filaments, Thomas Edison provide us with a good lesson to advance any venture. He said "I have not failed, I've just found 10,000 ways that won't work." Advancing data and access interoperability is one of those ventures difficult to achieve because of the differences among the participating communities. Even within the marine domain, different communities exist and with them different technologies (formats and protocols) to publish data and its descriptions, and different vocabularies to name things (e.g. parameters, sensor types). Simplifying the heterogeneity of technologies is not only accomplished by adopting standards, but by creating profiles, and advancing tools that use those standards. In some cases, standards are advanced by building from existing tools. But what is the best strategy? Edison could provide us a hint. Prototypes and test beds are essential to achieve interoperability among geospatial communities. The Open Geospatial Consortium (OGC) calls them interoperability experiments. The World Wide Web Consortium (W3C) calls them incubator projects. Prototypes help test and refine specifications. The Marine Metadata Interoperability (MMI) Initiative, which is advancing marine data integration and re-use by promoting community solutions, understood this strategy and started an interoperability demonstration with the SURA Coastal Ocean Observing and Prediction (SCOOP) program. This interoperability demonstration transformed into the OGC Ocean Science Interoperability Experiment (Oceans IE). The Oceans IE brings together the Ocean-Observing community to advance interoperability of ocean observing systems by using OGC Standards. The Oceans IE Phase I investigated the use of OGC Web Feature Service (WFS) and OGC Sensor Observation Service (SOS) standards for representing and exchanging point data records from fixed in-situ marine platforms. The Oceans IE Phase I produced an engineering best practices report, advanced reference implementations, and submitted various change requests that are now being considered by the OGC SOS working group. Building on Phase I, and with a focus on semantically-enabled services, Oceans IE Phase II will continue the use and improvement of OGC specifications in the marine community. We will present the lessons learned and in particular the strategy of experimenting with technologies to advance standards to publish data in marine communities, which could also help advance interoperability in other geospatial communities. We will also discuss the growing collaborations among ocean-observing standards organizations that will bring about the institutional acceptance needed for these technologies and practices to gain traction globally.

http://www.oostethys.org/ogc-oceans-interoperability-experiment